Located at 5006 NY-23, Oneonta, NY 13820, Molly’s Pizza has established itself as a welcoming destination for those seeking a genuine and satisfying dining experience. Our establishment is built on the simple philosophy that great food starts with quality ingredients and a commitment to traditional preparation methods. Whether you are a local resident or passing through the beautiful landscape of upstate New York, we invite you to step inside and enjoy a meal crafted with care and consistency.
At Molly’s Pizza, we understand that a restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it is a space where community members gather, friends catch up, and families share moments over a warm meal. Our kitchen team focuses on the fundamentals of pizza making, ensuring that every pie that leaves our oven meets our standards for flavor and texture. We take pride in our location along the NY-23 corridor, serving as a reliable stop for travelers and a favorite neighborhood spot for the people of Oneonta.
We believe that the secret to a memorable pizza lies in the balance of the crust, the richness of the sauce, and the quality of the toppings. By maintaining a steady focus on these core elements, we provide a dining experience that feels both familiar and exceptional. Our team is dedicated to maintaining a clean, comfortable, and inviting atmosphere where every guest feels valued from the moment they arrive until they finish their last slice.
What Makes Our Kitchen Special
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: We prioritize sourcing reliable components for our dough, sauces, and toppings to ensure that every bite reflects our dedication to culinary standards.
Traditional Preparation Methods: Our approach honors the classic techniques of pizza making, focusing on proper fermentation and precise oven temperatures to achieve the perfect crust.
Community-Focused Atmosphere: Situated conveniently on NY-23, our restaurant serves as a central hub for the local Oneonta community, offering a relaxed environment for all occasions.
Consistency in Every Order: We strive to provide a reliable experience, ensuring that whether you are dining in or picking up, the quality of your meal remains our top priority.
Beyond our signature pizzas, we aim to provide a comprehensive experience that caters to the preferences of our diverse clientele. We recognize that our guests have different tastes, and we work hard to ensure our menu offerings are prepared with the same level of attention and detail. Our staff is trained to provide efficient and friendly service, helping to make your visit as smooth and enjoyable as possible. We are grateful for the support of the Oneonta community and look forward to continuing our tradition of serving quality food to our neighbors and visitors alike.
As we look toward the future, our goal remains unchanged: to be a staple in the local food scene by staying true to our roots. We invite you to visit us at 5006 NY-23 to discover why so many people choose us when they are craving a quality meal. We are constantly refining our processes to better serve our customers, and we appreciate the feedback that helps us grow and improve. Thank you for considering Molly’s Pizza for your next meal; we look forward to welcoming you to our table soon.
Join Us for Your Next Meal
If you find yourself in the Oneonta area, we encourage you to stop by and experience what we have to offer firsthand. Molly’s Pizza is more than just a name; it is a commitment to providing a high-quality, honest, and delicious dining option for everyone who walks through our doors. We are proud to be a part of the local landscape and remain dedicated to the craft of pizza making. Whether you are planning a casual lunch or a relaxed dinner, we are here to provide a satisfying experience that hits the spot every time. We look forward to serving you and becoming a regular part of your dining routine in the heart of New York.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Menus
Photos
Reviews Molly’s Pizza
Val Chum
30-05-2026
Pizza is good here. Guy runs a one man operation from what I saw. Impressive. I like the pizza the sauce is sweet. The crust is good and holds up when you fold it. I will be a regular here. More
keith hoffman
30-05-2026
Best pizza in Oneonta! The crust is amazing and he's generous with his toppings.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
J Moses Browning
30-05-2026
First time trying Molly's. Very pleased and will frequent this place. Pizza done just right, vegetable toppings not over cooked, generous size, and tastes great. Well done. Highly recommended. More
RJ Bernard
30-05-2026
There were only 2 good pizza shops in Oneonta, now there are 3. Excellent, pizza, great crust, heavy on the toppings. I got it delivered and the crust was still crisp. Best prices it town too. I'll be back for more. More
Ashley Kirby
30-05-2026
Best veggie pizza in town! Loaded with veggies and the ricotta cheese mixture has a ton of flavor.
Or…
More
keith hoffman
30-05-2026
Best pizza in Oneonta! The crust is amazing and he's generous with his toppings.
Food: 5…
More
Elexis Wilcox
30-05-2026
Omg the pizza is so consistent and absolutely amazing here! Never ever had a bad experience! Love the Sicilian and any white pizza from here, also the ranch is soo amazing! More
R D
30-05-2026
Molly's pizza has to be the best pizza in the area. This is the best pizza I've had since Renna's in the Olean NY mall. Renna's pizza has been a legend in Olean NY for 40+ years. I've never had pizza even remotely as good over the past 40 … More
Nikki Hadlock
30-05-2026
We are from out of town, ordered 4 pies to share with family. Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had! The meat lovers is loaded with toppings. The price is more than fair. We will order again when we are back in the area! More
Ian Austin
30-05-2026
When if comes to Pizza in Oneonta, you better bring your A-Game, and as I can tell you, after trying Molly's for the first time this past week, they certainly have! … More
Maddie Schiller
30-05-2026
Great service, amazing pizza. Probably my favorite crust.
Jo Shmo
30-05-2026
The level of customer service is above and beyond! I was picking up a large order for a work lunch and he actually carried all of the 5 boxes out for me and he was the only one there! The pizza was AMAZING!!! LOVE THE CRUST! Thanks for the great service 😁 … More
Melanie von Bose
30-05-2026
We stopped in this shopping area on our way through town and needed a quick dinner. I'm so glad we chose Molly's Pizza! The owner was kind and helpful. The pizza was divine. Service was quick, the food was a great price, and I would absolutely eat here again. More
Joe T
30-05-2026
Only bad thing I can say about this place is that it’s not bigger for more ppl to sit & enjoy the ONLY GOOD (GREAT PIZZA!!) in the area!!! This is a hidden gold mine!!!! Been around here for years visiting and this is the ONLY PLACE THAT … More
Jared Gero
30-05-2026
I place a large order of pizzas once a year for an event at NYST and this pizza place knocks it out of the park everytime. I give him 24 hours notice and the 15 plus pizzas are hot and ready right during lunch time. Every special pizza is … More
Cheri Dietzman
30-05-2026
The pizza here is terrific! Talk about not skimping on toppings - these pies are heavily laden with toppings. The sauce is good and so is the crust. Excellent! We think it's the best pizza in the area and we tell everyone we know that it is! More
Damien Burch
30-05-2026
Pizza is delicious. In a town with many good pizza places, this place isn’t talked about enough. I had the mollys cheese pizza with half pepperoni and some garlic knots… perfection. My only “complaint” I might have is that I can agree with other costumers that the owner might be a little stiff. Could be because he’s always busy and sometimes as the owner, you take on the stress of all the jobs at hand. Regardless of that… great pizza.
Order type
Take out
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Pies
Nathan Beaman (Srosski528)
30-05-2026
Stumbled upon Molly's while working in the area. I was a little hesitant at first but once I tried the pizza I knew it wouldn't be my last time. The sauce is homemade and there is no shortage of toppings on the slices. I have had the … More
Ashley B
30-05-2026
The presumed owner is extremely rude. Completely ignored me the first time I came in and was just flat out unfriendly when I asked him the prices. Then I tried going in a second time and he was helping someone with the doors closed from the … More
Bradley Richmond
30-05-2026
Wifey and I were visiting and decided to have pizza. Molly's was absolutely delicious. The wait was 20 min not bad at all. Walked in to see 2 gentlemen running the show. Mollys is absolutely worth it. If we come back out this way, Molly's is were we are eating. More
Matthew Hamilton
30-05-2026
The food was extremely good and I can tell that it was fresh. Not dripping with grease. A great place to go More
Gary Yearsley
30-05-2026
A hidden Gem in plain sight . The pizza is phenomenal. Felt like I was back in the city . Absolutely awesome . Best pizza I have had in months . If your passing through or at the mall you got to try it . More
Samantha Escobar
30-05-2026
Molly’s pizza is delicious. Their pizza is very flavorful which other pizza places lack. My favorite is either a plain slice, Sicilian, or a white cheese slice with broccoli. Even my family that visits from the city always asks to get a Molly’s pie when they are in town. Thank you for your great pizza! More
P D
30-05-2026
Best pizza in Oneonta. Just wasted money AGAIN, trying a place across town last night, Found MOLLYS today and it's Amazing. You will LOVE this pizza. More
Ariel
30-05-2026
Really loved the pizza 🍕! I had white sauce pizza with broccoli and chicken. I also had a slice of pepperoni 🍕. Both were cooked perfectly. The down side the soda machine was down,but they had canned soda so, I gave them a solid 4 stars ⭐️. …
Theresa Yejin Chung
30-05-2026
Best pizza in Oneonta and even approved by NYC natives! Vegetarian pizza is overflowing with fresh veggies; every part of the pizza is covered in a pile of broccoli, mushrooms, peppers, tomato, and cheese. Highly recommend the thin-crust … More
Alyssa Zynda
30-05-2026
I visit with my daughters frequently. One of my favorite local pizza places! We get the garlic ricotta pizza half cheese and knots!
Order type
Take out
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pies
Heather B. Denture DiVa
30-05-2026
So I came here twice to give them the benefit of the doubt to try their Pizza and in this town we have a ton of pizza everywhere I would say this one is the one that I would not recommend. And plus no matter what your political beliefs are you probably shouldn't be chatting with people saying horrendous things in front of kids. Never mix business with politics. But I would never recommend their pizzas aside from any of that before I knew when my son went with his grandfather she get shoes for school and the things he told me that this guy said who owned the business I don't know it's more garlic than anything and it's not cohesive with the pizza hut. There's many other pizza places I would recommend more
Food: 2
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 1
TamRootbeer
30-05-2026
We heard about this pizza place recently and decided we had to try it (our granddaughter's name is Molly). It was excellent, had plenty of pepperoni, and the crust was flavorful and had that slight chewiness we love. Excellent price!
I did ask if they had gluten free crust, but they do not.
Please like this review if you found it helpful.
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
kristy williams
30-05-2026
Hubby stopped after work to grab a pizza. He got a meat lovers pizza (don’t know what the official name is) and it was huge. lol There was so much toppings. It was delicious. I ate one slice and was full. You definitely get your money’s worth. So good!
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Juan Lima
30-05-2026
The pizza here is fantastic. Can't get enough of that crust which is reminiscent of Brooklyn style pizza from NYC. We had their large mushroom pie with fresh mushrooms and a Schweppes and Canada Dry soda flavors we haven't had before. The owner was friendly and it wasn't very busy until after we left. Had the rest of the pie to go.
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Reviews Molly’s Pizza